RUME 9
2006
Piscataway, New Jersey
Students’ Proofs for the Shapes of Graphs of Solutions in the Phase Plane
Page: -1
This paper reports on student proofs for the shapes of graphs of solutions in the phase plane for systems of two linear homogenous differential equations with constant coefficients. We define proof to be an argument and we draw on Toulmin’s scheme for the anatomy of an argument. Data for this analysis comes from an eight-week teaching experiment conducted in an undergraduate differential equations course in a large southwestern university. We found that students’ proofs relied on six sources (data) for the basis of their claims. In our presentation we will illustrate and clarify the students’ deductive arguments for solution graph shapes. Findings from our research contribute to contemporary characterizations of proof as a social process. The presentation will conclude with implications for teaching and instructional design.