RUME 9
2006
Piscataway, New Jersey
Is this the answer? Is this what I was supposed to do? Control Structures in Introductory Calculus Textbooks
Page: -1
Preliminary report of an analysis of 9 introductory calculus textbooks that looked at strategies available to students for (1) determining whether an action was relevant when solving a problem and (2) deciding that the problem was solved. This is known as the control structure, and it plays an important role in using validation strategies in mathematics. The books differ in terms of audience (Honors, Regular, Applied, Science & Engineering) and in terms of influence by the calculus reform movement. The study describes the control strategies that are present in lessons and examples associated with the derivative (~800 examples) and establishes differences across textbooks. There are two main hypotheses in this study: (1) Strategies tend to rely more on content at stake in books intended for honors students, and (2) Reform oriented textbooks provide the control structure more explicitly. Results have implications for research, teaching assistant training, and teaching.