site icon

Proving Styles in Advanced Mathematics

If any information below is incorrect, please login and use the links below to correct it

Missing path icon

RUME 10

2007

San Diego, CA

Proving Styles in Advanced Mathematics

Page: -1

Research in advanced mathematical thinking suggests that there are at least two qualitatively distinct ways that students may productively reason about advanced mathematical concepts (e.g., Vinner, 1991; Raman, 2003). Individuals can reason about concepts by focusing primarily on their definitions and using logic to deduce properties about the concept from these definitions. Alternatively, they coordinate their image of the concept (cf., Tall & Vinner, 1981) with its formal definition and use both to determine what properties the concept may have (e.g., Vinner, 1991; Pinto & Tall, 1999). Although both modes of reasoning are worthwhile, several studies on students' reasoning in real analysis suggest many students predominantly use only a single mode of reasoning to think about formal concepts (e.g., Alcock & Simpson, 2004, 2005; Pinto & Tall, 1999, 2002). The goal of this presentation is to extend and generalize this research by examining students' reasoning styles in another context and another domain. Specifically, we will examine the ways that undergraduates attempt to construct proofs in a transition-to-proof course. The goal of this presentation is to document the existence of undergraduates' proving styles-that is, we will show that some students consistently base their proof attempts on their informal images of the involved concepts while other students never use their concept image when they construct proofs and instead focus on logical rules and manipulations.

Editors may log in and edit entries here with permissions.