RUME 10
2007
San Diego, CA
A Framework for Developing Algebraic Understanding & Procedural Skill: An Initial Assessment
Page: -1
This study examined the effectiveness of instruction based upon Burke’s (2001) Framework for Procedural Understanding. The Framework is designed to help students develop deep procedural knowledge, which presumably facilitates recall and promotes future learning. The quasi-experimental design paired six college algebra instructors according to teaching experience, and the instructional treatment was assigned to one member of each pair. Students’ ACT/SAT scores established the equivalence of treatment and control groups. Data consisted of classroom observations, homework samples, common hour exams, procedural understanding assessments, supplemental course evaluations, and interviews with treatment instructors. An ANCOVA revealed that treatment group students scored significantly higher than control group students on procedural understanding. Moreover, although treatment students were assigned fewer drill questions, no significant differences were detected in procedural skill. Overall, students possessing procedural understanding exhibited greater procedural skill, regardless of instructional approach. Interviews with treatment instructors revealed implementation issues surrounding Framework-based instruction.