RUME 12
2009
Raleigh, NC
Proving is Not Convincing
Page: -1
The majority of mathematics educators would agree to at least one of the following statements. (a) If an argument is completely convincing to an individual or a community, then it is a mathematical proof (to that individual or community). (b) If an argument is not completely convincing to an individual or a community, then it is not a proof (to that individual or community). Based on data from interviews with ten mathematicians, as well as other findings in the mathematics education literature, I will argue both claims are false. Further, I will contend that our community’s acceptance of these claims has led us to draw inappropriate inferences from existing data and offer dubious pedagogical suggestions.