site icon

Proving is Not Convincing

If any information below is incorrect, please login and use the links below to correct it

Missing path icon

RUME 12

2009

Raleigh, NC

Proving is Not Convincing

Page: -1

The majority of mathematics educators would agree to at least one of the following statements. (a) If an argument is completely convincing to an individual or a community, then it is a mathematical proof (to that individual or community). (b) If an argument is not completely convincing to an individual or a community, then it is not a proof (to that individual or community). Based on data from interviews with ten mathematicians, as well as other findings in the mathematics education literature, I will argue both claims are false. Further, I will contend that our community’s acceptance of these claims has led us to draw inappropriate inferences from existing data and offer dubious pedagogical suggestions.

Editors may log in and edit entries here with permissions.