RUME 12
2009
Raleigh, NC
Different Ways of Assessing the Persuasiveness of Mathematical Arguments
Page: -1
Several recent studies have suggested that there are two different ways in which a person can proceed when assessing the persuasiveness of a mathematical argument: by evaluating the extent to which it is personally convincing, or by evaluating the extent to which it is publicly acceptable. In this presentation we use Toulmin’s (1958) argumentation scheme to describe a more detailed classification of the different ways in which students may assess the persuasiveness of an argument. We suggest that there are (at least) five different ways in which such an evaluation may take place. This classification is illustrated with data from an interview study that tracked the development of students’ argument evaluation behavior across the course of an undergraduate mathematics degree.