RUME 12
2009
Raleigh, NC
What makes a textbook proof a satisfactory explanation for the reader?
Page: -1
This preliminary research report describes an ongoing project investigating the factors that influence a reader's acceptance of a proof as a satisfactory explanation. This study examines one potential factor: the metaphorical language of the proof. When reading a proof involving continuity, does a reader's metaphorical understanding of continuity influence their acceptance of the proof as an explanation? I interviewed students in an undergraduate Analysis course to determine their metaphorical understanding of continuity. Most students understood continuity dynamically, speaking of \jumps" and movement. I will interview the subjects again, and present them with three proofs of the same result. While the proofs are structurally equivalent, they dier in the metaphorical language in which they are couched. The collection of empirical data is ongoing.